Shower or Bathtub: Which One is Right for Your Bathroom?



Discover What Works Best for Your Space

When it comes to bathroom design, one of the biggest decisions homeowners face is whether to install a shower, a bathtub—or both. It might seem like a simple choice, but this decision can impact your home’s style, functionality, and even resale value. So, let’s dive into the pros and cons of showers vs. bathtubs and help you decide what’s best for your space and lifestyle.


The Shower: Sleek, Efficient, and Modern

Showers have become the go-to option for many homeowners, especially in homes where space is at a premium or the bathroom needs a modern, minimalist touch.

Pros of a Shower:

  • Saves Space: Great for small bathrooms or en-suites.
  • Quick and Convenient: Perfect for busy mornings.
  • Water Efficient: Uses less water than most traditional bathtubs.
  • Accessible: Walk-in showers with no threshold are ideal for aging in place or for anyone with mobility issues.
  • Modern Appeal: Frameless glass doors and rain showerheads add an elegant, spa-like feel.

Cons of a Shower:

  • No Soaking Option: If you love to soak, a shower might feel like it’s missing something.
  • Less Kid-Friendly: Bathing young children can be trickier in a shower.
  • Lower Resale Appeal (sometimes): Families often look for homes with at least one bathtub.

The Bathtub: Classic Comfort and Relaxation

Bathtubs offer a nostalgic, luxurious feel. Whether it’s a freestanding clawfoot tub or a deep soaking tub, bathtubs can create a relaxing escape within your home.

Pros of a Bathtub:

  • Ideal for Relaxation: A long soak in warm water is therapeutic for both body and mind.
  • Great for Kids: Easier for bathing toddlers and small children.
  • Higher Resale Value in Some Markets: Homes with at least one tub are often more appealing to families.
  • Variety of Styles: Freestanding, alcove, corner, whirlpool—lots of options for different aesthetics.

Cons of a Bathtub:

  • Takes Up More Space: Not always ideal for small bathrooms.
  • Uses More Water: Less eco-friendly than a quick shower.
  • Not as Accessible: Climbing in and out can be difficult for some people.
  • Slower Experience: Not the best choice if you’re always in a rush.

Shower or Bathtub: What’s Right for Your Home?

When deciding between a shower or a bathtub, ask yourself the following:

  • How much space do I have? If you’re limited on square footage, a shower may be more practical.
  • Who lives in the home? Families with young kids may prefer a tub, while singles or couples may lean toward a sleek shower.
  • How do I relax? If baths are your go-to for stress relief, a tub might be non-negotiable.
  • Am I planning to sell soon? Think about what will appeal to future buyers in your market.
  • What style do I love? Showers can feel high-end and modern; bathtubs bring charm and tradition.

The Best of Both Worlds?

If space and budget allow, having both a shower and a tub gives you flexibility and boosts your home’s value. A popular option is the shower-tub combo, which combines practicality and comfort, especially in smaller bathrooms. For luxury bathrooms, a separate walk-in shower and freestanding tub is the dream.


So, What Do You Prefer?

Are you or ? Let us know in the comments! And if you’re planning a bathroom renovation, take time to think about how your space works for you—not just what looks good in a magazine. After all, your bathroom should be a place of both function and peace.